Fresh, Home style Baked Goods & More 

Welcome to Schlabach's Bakery ∙ A Family Owned Amish Tradition since 1970!

Homestyle Baked Goods

Treat Yourself to our homestyle Amish favorites, and traditional made-from-scratch baked goods! Use the dropdown below to find your favorite products, or Contact Us to place an order.

Filter Products...
  • All
  • Breads
  • Brownies
  • Cakes
  • Cookies
  • Doughnuts
  • Fried Pies
  • Granola
  • Jams & Spreads
  • Nut Breads
  • Pies
  • Pumpkin Nut Roll
  • Sweet Rolls

Serve up a taste of heaven with a slice of angel food cake! Top with whipped cream and berries for a light, refreshing dessert.

Shop Now

Fresh, homestyle breads - multiple types available. What is more comforting than warm homemade bread? Baked fresh every morning, our breads are a fan favorite - a tasty addition to any meal. Pair it with our homemade Jams for a delectable treat!

Shop Now

These brownies are baked to perfection - crispy edges with soft and chewy centers. From the classic fudge, to the lightly tart lemon bar, there's a favorite flavor for everyone!

Shop Now

Got a birthday coming up? Our cakes are perfect for any celebration! From rich fudgy goodness to light coconut sweetness, there are various mouth-watering flavors sure to please any palate.

Shop Now

Nothing beats a cookie for a tasteful snack! Pour a glass of milk and enjoy one (or two!) chunky cookies bursting with chips and buttery flavor!

Shop Now

Welcome our seasonal cupcakes! These cakes are perfect for any celebration! With a rich chocolatey cake, and creamy icing these cakes are a sweet addition to any picnic! Comes in a pack of 2 or 4.

Shop Now

These soft, yeasty dinner rolls are perfect for serving with any meal - or for a quick snack with peanut butter and jelly!

Shop Now

Try our delicious Donuts - our Saturday morning Special! These melt-in-your mouth donuts are the OG of baked goodies at Schlabach's Bakery. Try the chocolate-glazed doughnuts for a fudgy twist on the original.

Shop Now

These simple homestyle egg noodles are completely made from scratch. Especially delicious in soups, or cooked in chicken broth.

Shop Now

Page [tcb_pagination_current_page] of [tcb_pagination_total_pages]

Baked Goods for Fundraisers & Events

We are proud to have served this community with excellent food for years, and are dedicated to helping those in need. Over the years we have held many fundraisers to help various organizations including schools, churches, youth sports, and clubs. Shop now, or Register today for exclusive pricing on your next fund-raising event!

50 Years Of Mixing Batter

Schlabach's Bakery first began making delicious doughnuts and fresh bread back in 1970. From there it quickly expanded to earn a spot in the hearts of locals and visitors. Over 50 years later, not much has changed — we’re still a family-owned bakery, baking traditional Amish Favorites with simple ingredients and a lot of love.

Made From Scratch

All our baked goods are hand made from scratch, and do not contain preservatives or artificial ingredients. 

Baked Fresh Daily

Our breads, sweet rolls, and fried pies are baked fresh every day, and every Saturday morning there are fresh donuts - while they last!

Family Owned

Family owned and operated,  Schlabach's Bakery has been serving the community for over 50 years. 

Schlabach's Bakery - A Family Tradition

It all began in a farmhouse kitchen, where, armed with her own, traditional recipes, a mother shared her baking skills to provide for her family.

Since then, this country bakery has become a well known and visited spot for the people of Guthrie, Kentucky and tourists alike. Schlabach's Bakery continues serving families classic Amish Favorites and homemade goodness in every bite! 

Our Fans Love Us!

Francis M.

Delighted Client

They have a wonderful bakery. The personnel are friendly and knowledgeable. We go at least every other week, can't resist their fresh bakery goods!

Rosalee Lugo

Delighted Client

This bakery is THE BEST. All of their goods are great. We especially love their Fried Pies, with apple and peach being our favorites. They make all their goods from scratch with great quality ingredients. In addition, we've enjoyed their Cinnamon Rolls, Brownies, Oatmeal Cream Pies, Choco pies, Lemon bars, Sourdough Bread and the 100% pure honey.

Brenda Schlabach

Friend & client

Best bakery in town! I personally love the doughnuts, raisin bread, and the cinnamon rolls. Friendly staff and great services, definitely my favorite place to get sweets!  

Got an Event or Fundraiser? We're Ready To Help!

Got a church, school, or organization event? Schedule a pickup time and your order will be ready! We also offer local delivery or shipping!